Archive for April 2010
The End of April
This is something new: I don’t want April to end. For the first time in such a long, long time, April has something in it that i cannot bear to let go.
April 2010. The month our son Freddie was born and lived and died. A son. A boy. A brother.
I don’t have a picture to show off the little boy who should be 4 weeks old today.
I have one of the first time we held him and that has to be enough.
I have one of the brightest, most glorious rainbow arching across the sky behind the house today, one i might have held him up to see; his first rainbow.
But i do not have our baby.
I just don’t have the words. But i am very grateful to a friend who wrote this beautiful post for us and for our son. Sometimes it snows in April. It is so much gentler and more dignified than i feel right now.
Other Stuff

Maddy playing rugby in an end of season tournament with lots of other local clubs. (Some serious dad involvement in the shouting from the sidelines!)

Playing on bikes the day after Max and i came home from the hospital.

Swan Pond – Maddy’s Hama Bead swan pond model from the night before Freddie was born. Rather fabulous

Genetics at the dinner table (it is a long time since GCSE biology) – trying to explain why we are all different, how people have elements of their family and why Freddie might possibly have had something wrong with him that came from one of us and only showed up because he was a boy. Or might not. (Back to not knowing anything again.)

Easter Crafts; house is littered with them, mostly done without me being around.

Flowers for Freddie. Sometimes i think my heart will break because to refer to myself as mummy when i think of him or talk to him in my head, just doesn’t feel quite natural. I never really got to be mummy to him.
Balancing it up.
Life goes on. Seems to be the only thing i can think of to say about it really. And it really does go on; other lives, other events and you quickly realise that you and yours are just a tiny part of a much bigger picture. Even in hospital with Freddie we watched a Brian Cox thing one night and i thought “here i am, crying for my sick baby and i’m just a tiny dot, on a tiny dot, in a tiny drop of water, on a tiny ball in a huge, enormous **** off universe that can’t even hear me cry.” It is a bizarre thought. Human emotions are so big, so all encompassing, so complete – it is impossible to imagine things beyond your own thoughts sometimes.
When Freddie went off to another hospital for a brain scan, Max and i were shown the little incubator cart he would go in. I immediately retreated from it and knew i couldn’t go with him (there were lots of other reasons for not doing so) because that was the same style of little cart that almost 12 years earlier Fran was taken to her first operation in. I sobbed all the way through the hospital as we walked with her to the theatres that day, in the same hospital that Freddie was being taken to. Afterwards, once we’d decided to let Freddie go on without us, Max said “in some ways you just want to go and slap yourself round the face for thinking that Fran’s operation was worth getting frightened about but in other ways you have to remember what a big deal it did feel at the time. And was.”
I’m not a believer in hierarchies of stress and pain and fear and grief – a child who dreams of monsters is just as scared at the moment as they can imagine being and it doesn’t matter to them that somewhere else a child has just lost its mother, or seen a person die or been beaten or damaged. Fear is fear. People say “worse thing happen at sea” but i doubt that is much comfort to the person about to fall off a tall building. My children sobbed for their rabbit 3 weeks before Freddie was born with the same intensity and sadness that they cried for him. People mourn for many things. When Fran needed that operation, i was terrified she was going to die and powerless to help her; 10 days of knowing Freddie was probably going to die or perhaps worse, might manage to live, was not really worse than that, it was just different. I’ve had the healthiest child in SCBU and the sickest and i can’t say that one was particularly less frightening or tear inducing than the other. But then i do cry a lot, so perhaps i am not the best barometer of such things. Certainly the most frightened i have ever been in my life was the moments after Freddie was born, nothing really compares to that, but watching him die was not one of the worst moments of my life. Well. It was. But it wasn’t. I was heartbroken, bereft and full of loss. But also relieved and at peace and sure that the right thing had happened. And i was cuddling my boy, without drips or beeps, for the only time in his or my life. So how could it be the worst moment?
No, i wouldn’t slap myself round the face on the day of Fran’s first operation, when she was exactly the same age as Freddie was on the day he died. If i could have a moment with myself, i think i would want to say that one day i was going to need the memory of that time to get me through another time and that i would be stronger and more able because of it. It wouldn’t have helped me to know there were people in worse positions, or even that one day i would be in one. I doubt very much it would have helped the people in the room with sick children to know that i was in a better position. Bad things happen and they tend to just feel really bad at the time. If you are ill-equipped to deal with such things (as i am and Max apparently isn’t) then you are likely to handle them badly. I’ve handled Freddie’s life and death better than i’ve handled any other crisis in my life – and that is weird, given it certainly ought to be appear to be the worst position we have ever been in. I guess that might be because no one else ever really knows where you are in your heart – from the outside a situation might seem clear cut but if you are in it, with all the baggage that goes along with people and couples and secrets, something else might be true.
Freddie’s death might seem like the worst thing that could possibly have happened to us; the truth is that i happen to have enough knowledge of how things might have turned out, thanks to my friend Kate, to know that things might well have been more devastating if he had lived. That sounds so heartless but it isn’t – but the reality is probably that we have got out of jail -Â not free but only scarred- and he and the girls have probably been spared a life time of pain and regret and frustration and obligation. The down side, the black lining to the cloud, is that we can’t ever really know. And we can’t wipe this experience away from any of the 6 of us left behind.
Freddie’s Day
Today was Freddie’s funeral, the first part of it anyway, as we plan a memorial with friends and family later. We didn’t feel this part would be helpful for the girls to attend and felt if we were caring for them, it wouldn’t be helpful for us either so decided to have a private service. Somehow the idea of accommodating the needs of others felt too hard, a service for a baby almost nobody met felt wrong and family without the girls also felt wrong. Initially it was just going to be just Max and i but in the end several SCBU nurses asked to come and we invited the midwife and 2 doctors, plus one very special friend who has a foot in the hospital camp and also in our world. Otherwise i somehow wanted it to be people i never had to meet again if i chose not to; there are so many people who were part of my pregnancy, specifically my lovely doula, who i do want to see again but who i associate with life, not death. The people who came felt very right in the end.
There are going to be far too few posts on this blog about Freddie and in time even the posts of sadness and reflection will fade away. We’ve had so much support from people on here that it feels right to do a sort of virtual funeral and so i thought i would record what was said and spoken and played. It was a very beautiful service and i got more peace from it than i thought i would. The chaplain from the hospital was very sympathetic to our wishes and kept it spiritual without being overtly Christian and we were very grateful for how special he, and the people who came, made it. Various little parts of the service had been contributed to by my friends, online/real life friends who know me inside out and back to front and who have held me and Max together in the last few weeks.
The music was sent to me by my friend Sarah and was just perfect. It was “Song for Kim” by Nick and Anita Haigh. I listened to it lots when i was writing my letter to Freddie and lots yesterday; all those times i sobbed to listen to it but today it calmed me and helped me get through saying goodbye to our baby.
I spent all Sunday searching for a poem; i felt there just had to be the perfect one out there but i couldn’t find it. Then i happened upon one called Early Death and with the help of friends, i rewrote it to suit Freddie and his short life. It felt perfect.
He slipped away like morning dew
Before the sun was high;
So brief his time, he scarcely knew
The meaning of a sigh.
As round the rose its soft perfume,
Sweet love around him floated;
Admired he slept – while mortal doom
Crept on, unfeared, unnoted.
Love was his guardian Angel here,
Though Love to Death resigned him;
But in our thoughts and hearts he’s near
And seeking there, we find him.
I’d hoped to read this myself but from the minute i saw the car draw up with him inside, i knew i couldn’t. I was pretty much undone from the start. How Max kept his composure, including carrying him in, i have no idea. He was amazing. He wrote and read his own words to Freddie and has allowed me to put them here.
Dear Freddie,
If I could speak to you now this is what I’d say. I am so sad and sorry that you did not get to live the life that you should have done. And what a life you would have had. No parents could have given you more love and support than your mother and me. No brother could have been better loved and cared for than you would have been by your four sisters, Frances, Maddy, Amelie and Josie. You would never have been short of someone to play with, to talk with, to be cuddled by, and to be inspired by.
When I think back to your short life I know there was terrible worry and despair but it only the good times that I can remember now. I remember the joy and comfort I got from seeing you and from touching you. I remember seeing how much you drew comfort by being held by your mother and by me, how you would relax and look like you felt safe and where you should be. I remember the joy your sisters felt in bringing you presents and telling you about them. I remember that short time when you opened your eyes and looked into mine, that moment we shared together, father and son.
Now we will carry on with our lives to make sure that we make the most of the precious time that we have together, to live out our hopes and dreams, and to be a good family. You will always be a loved member of our family. You will always be our beautiful baby boy, our Freddie.
I love him for always seeing the glass half full, for being able to remember the good and special. He inspires me with his ability to do that.
Finally the chaplain read my letter to Freddie. I found this so hard to write; i certainly couldn’t have read it out.
Freddie,
This is not how it is supposed to be. We were not supposed to end our nine months together with you hurtling out into nothing, to a place where the very last person who could help you was me. You were not supposed to live your life barely held by us, barely awake and enduring endless needles and tests and tubes. You were not supposed to live your life with my tears raining down on you.
I want to tell you how it should have been. I want to have the time to let you feel my arms first, my breast for food and comfort, my voice for night after night as you learned to live . I want to be the first one to have dressed you and cared for you and changed your nappy. I want to show your beautiful, peaceful face to everyone and laugh at how, as it turns out, i rather like being mummy to a boy after all. I want to tell our story proudly, looking down at you as you sleep in my arms. I wanted to see you walk in front of me, holding your sisters’ hands. I wanted to see you run and hear you shout.
I wanted to see you loved and spoiled by the sisters who were ready and waiting to adore you. I wanted to tell you that you had Amelie’s mouth, Josie’s nose, Maddy’s face, Fran’s eyes and Daddy’s dimpled chin until you yelled back that actually you were Freddie, not little parts of everyone else in the family. I wanted to hear you in a temper, in a rage and laughing and loving life.
I never thought that motherhood could be reduced to being desperate to see you open your eyes, or being grateful forever for the times that you did. The look in your eyes when you did has been scalded into my heart.
I want to tell you that you were the most adorable bump, who seemed to know when i needed to hear from you. I want to remember every kick and every wriggle, how you made me laugh when you back flipped in a one day and made me shriek out loud. I want to tell you that you gave me not a moments trouble, that i loved all that time i had with you, that even late night hiccups and the heartburn and that even though i worried ceaselessly about you, i didn’t begrudge you a moment of it. I wanted to tell you that you might have come last in the family, 5 years after the others but that you were the most considered, the most planned, the most thought about of all our babies. You were a most precious and wanted full stop, one we had changed everything about our future to accommodate.
I want you to know that even though we did not force you to stay with us, that was not because we loved you less. I wanted a miracle for you but i also wanted what was best for you – and from the very first moment of your life, what was best for you was not what i had planned. I want to tell you that i can remember every cuddle we had together and treasure them all. That every move you made seemed like magic and every sound a song. I want to say out loud that i saw you hear my voice and turn to me, felt you squeeze my finger, watched you enjoying being held and that those were your milestones, precious, tiny ones that were just for us. I want you to know that you gave me something precious, that i will always remember, but that 11 days was not long enough for me to thank you for it.
Freddie – little boy – you will always be our child, loved and wanted, our little son. You will always be our baby boy, our fifth child, the one who made us 7.
A Life More Ordinary
We’re bumbling along. I think one of the most shocking things about all this suddenly being ‘a family with a dead child’ stuff is that an awful lot of life is going on just as normal. Partly i suppose that is because we are trying to make it so and partly perhaps because Freddie wasn’t really a part of home life, so the gap is not obvious in our daily life. All the gaps are in the future that now doesn’t exist as we expected it too but although Max and i have been through the hospital bit – the birth, the SCBU part and still have the awful parts of the formalities to go – the impact at home is not quite like it would be if it was one of the girls. And there is no cot, or nursery or anything else – because for whatever reason i felt profoundly odd about preparing for the baby and so didn’t do any of that. I always have in the past: i don’t know why i didn’t this time.
The girls are bumbling along okay; they’ve variously been doing bits of this book (a copy each) and reading some other books that either Michelle or i bought for them. The books have been a bit of a window on their souls really, quite fascinating if i was looking at it in a dispassionate sort of way. Unfortunately i’m not, i’m busy looking at my children processing grief and being somewhere between angry and heartbroken about it. Some other time i might write more privately about that.
We’ve had friends come to play and midwives who have visited and people who have looked after them while we keep appointments. And cards, lots and lots of cards. This April, Freddie’s April, the girls have crafted and played and bike ridden and weeded the garden for us and cried and cuddled. They’ve slept all in a room together and then gradually reasserted normality for themselves. And asked questions – lots and lots of questions. Ones like “can dead people be replaced?” and “why?” and “will it happen to x’s baby?” and Amelie has stared with forlorn longing into prams in supermarkets until she and i have stood in the middle of Tesco and both cried. I wish i had answers for any of the things they ask. I can’t even answer “why?”
I feel bad and i feel glad that in some ways i can carry on – i’m still the same rubbish mum who flaps at them to give me some space. The nagging fear i had that i wouldn’t actually like having a baby again has gone, because i miss him with a physical pain and sometimes, when i do the few things i rehearsed in my head like lying in bed and feeding him, i can hardly believe i can have really been pregnant. Because this is not how it is supposed to end. I feel like i’ve had a reverse phantom pregnancy. It feels bizarrely normal and utterly abnormal to be carrying on as before. It makes me wonder, a lot, about the strange disconnected feeling i had from being pregnant this time. Like i knew.
I think i did.
The girls have made me proud again this week. So here are videos of them enjoying life, for fun and to remind me that as i hovered over Freddie with the black clouds of future disability gathering on his horizon, i knew quite clearly where the joy in life is to be had. The joy in life is being able to do a round off flic tuck back if you want to. Or ride a bike with your dad. Or swing on a rope. Or read a book if you wish. Or colour a picture, or play in the street. No matter how much we reassured Freddie that we would love him whatever he could do, would make a life for him, have a job for him, we both knew that that was not what life should be.
To do whatever you want to be able to do, so long as it hurts no one, that is what life is.
Then of course, i go downstairs to help serve up our first half-in-the-garden barbecue of the year and from absolutely nowhere i’m overwhelmed by the absence of a car seat on the floor, ready for one of us to trip over, with a bright eyed 3 week old in it who might, just might, let me have five minutes of normal family meal time without needing a feed. And he isn’t there. He never has been. But i can still see the place where he should be.
23 April 2010
Life is not a Rehearsal.
Well. I don’t know. I’m beginning to think it possibly is. But not so much for the next life, perhaps more for whatever is coming along next in this one.
I was definitely a child who ‘over-felt’ things; i have a clear memory of weeping disconsolately, aged 7, on the edge of an olive green bath for two babies i had just heard of, had never met and never seen, who i discovered had died in a way that was entirely outside anything i needed to worry about. But i felt their loss rather keenly, mostly i think because i could only imagine that them being lost had rent a hole in the life of a person i loved.
When i was 18 a beautiful, full of life young man who i liked enormously, died in grim and dreadful circumstances; 17 years of life just smashed away and lost in a moment. I was utterly taken apart by that, well out of proportion, in the eyes of plenty of people. I don’t know why. Perhaps it was just a strong reaction to the reality that sometimes bad things do happen, perhaps it was just that it occurred at a moment when i was ripe for a change from child to adult and that particular event happened to gatecrash that particular time, sending it spinning off into an orbit i was not yet equipped to live in.
I don’t know. When i think back, i remember mostly just being raging about it, really, really angry that someone i liked, that all my friends liked, that was loved by people i cared about, who was full of life and fun and naughtiness and who i had grown up with, could be snatched away without any sort of due process. It seemed incomprehensible to me that fate could be so indiscriminate – that someone nice might died while someone nasty might not. I was dreadfully sad and i lost too much time thinking it was wrong to move on. It was April and the trees and flowers were bursting into life and no one, not even control freak me, could force the world to go back on its decision to remove N from life.
None of that is to say i wasn’t genuinely sad about him. He had been quite a force in our village, we moved in many of the same circles of Scouts and pubs and friends, had lived in the same village, knew the same people, been on holidays together, i was just as good friends with 2 of his brothers as i was with him. He was part of a loose network of people i was comfortable with, much outside the world of my school which i was quite uncomfortable with, but still part of that. I’d seen him in a pub for a drink a couple of weeks before, i’d congratulated him on passing his driving test and told him, dammit, to be careful in his new car.
One of the most wrenching images in my mind is something someone told me, not something i saw, of his parents walking hand in hand through the village early the day after. I remember thinking “i don’t know how they can bear it” and then later, becoming part of their family for a year after i went out with his brother, realising that actually, there wasn’t much bearing it at all. Or much choice about bearing it, whether they liked it or not. I remember going to that most wretched of funerals and holding hands with the boy from across the road, my eyes locked with the those of another lad opposite, who had shared a holiday with me and N. I remember thinking that almost as bad as feeling sad was witnessing seeing other people so sad and having absolutely nothing meaningful or useful to do for them or say to them.
Death, then, made me feel so powerless. I felt powerless all year long, locked inside that family – until me and the brother worked out that the only way forward was to move on and apart. And we all blew apart, all those friends who shared a hot and heady summer in the afterglow of school and N’s death, before going on to new lives. I don’t think it is any co-incidence that we’ve not really stayed in touch. Much too painful to remember a beautiful hot summer of late nights, love and laughter all framed with the bitterness of having lost something we barely even noticed we had until he was gone.
I remembered them all a few years later when i met my Gran-in-law. Within a few minutes she had mentioned her daughter, 15 years after her death. I wasn’t very old, only 21 or so but i think of that moment often. I remember thinking “Oh my god. Poor N’s mum. That pain never goes away.” It was a horrible thought that grief for a lost child never goes away, only gets so that you can talk about it.
No funeral or death has ever been quite so staggeringly bad as that first real brush with unfairness. Deaths from old age seem fair and kind by comparison and even ones which should have hurt – 2 mums i liked from my village who were connected to that hot summer, 2 school friends who chose to kill themselves, even the college friend who died just as N had done. I fled from all those really, particularly the college friend, not really able to face seeing people in pain. I think, for whatever reason, i feel grief too much, too fully and i can’t find any rationality in it. I think it comes down to the control freak in me – it makes me angry not to be able to stop that for the people who die or the people who hurt. For whatever reason, i’m unable to face it as my husband does, who until now had most certainly had the greater reason to hate death and fate, having lost his mother as a child. He seems to have an ability to face death as part of life, accept it, grieve in his own way and then move on, taking something peaceful with him, instead of carrying blistering coals. I don’t know how he does it, but i do admire it. And i’m trying to learn.
Four years ago today was the worst day of my life; death again and combined with rage and guilt and regret and despair – loss without the right to grieve, hurt without hope of repair. I sank as low, morally and spiritually, as i could ever go. I do not think it will ever be possible to cry as much as i did then, or for so long. I do not think i can ever crumble so hard, into such unfixable pieces, as i did then. I thought of those mothers and envied them their right to grieve and show and feel their loss. April again. Life bursting everywhere but not in me and the only thing that seemed possible was to somehow exist until life went away. It seemed as if, in one fleeting moment where i thought “hmm.. have i counted wrong… could i be…?” and then dismissed it, i brought my world to a crashing halt through no one’s fault but my own. I found myself on this day, the very worst of mothers for the very best of reasons. The worst of mothers because i tried to do the best for what i already had.
And now this. Freddie. A darling, wanted beautiful boy, a son, one i wanted and needed and begged for and grew and loved and adored. One we all wanted. Life and death again – and i can’t stop the hurt for any of the people i love.
I can’t help thinking that the day when i dismissed my counting inaccuracies wasn’t leading me to 23/4/06 at all. It was leading me here. Without that day, those other days would not have happened. Without that, Freddie would not have come into being because it would, or would not, have happened some other month and been some other child. So that error has led me here, ready if unwilling to face this, knowing that truthfully i know only too well that ‘this too shall pass’ and that i will recover. That we all will and all must. Because i have already been here – and i know that one day i will be able to look back and see it all for what it was. And will have moved on enough not to weep. That i have to teach my children that the dead do not admire people who stop living when they do, or thank them for it.
A beautiful boy. Freddie. Freddie who i would not choose to forget, would not choose to erase, would not choose to never have met. Freddie who showed me yet again that sometimes you have to do what is best for your children, even if it unbearably painful to yourself. Freddie who gave me, among his other gifts to me, permanent rightful entry to the unenviable club of women who have lost children. Freddie who has shown me, with the subtlety of a sledgehammer, that one event always seems to turn out to be simply part of another, another lesson waiting to be learned.
Freddie who gave me back April, the month in which he lived.





















a>
